Which quarterback would you rather have: Marino or Kelley?

[Taco John]

Vote!

[kelly]

i'm sure everyone is goin' to take a keen interest in this one :smash:

[CarMike]

Welcome to hR Taco John.

I voted for Dan Marino. Even though Jim Kelley could get the Bills to the SB, Dan Marino was the better QB of the two.

BTW, Taco John is the Admin from our newest member of IFS. Be sure to swing over to his MB and welcome them. He has a good group of posters there. Very courtious.

[Seebs]

Went with jim Kelly. At least he has 4 AFC titles...

[TexSkin]

No contest...Marino...the man was a beast just had bad luck with the teams he was on. He was one of the greatest QB's to play the game. Jim Kelly had a ton of support around him for those SB runs.

BTW welcome aboard Taco John

[PennSkinsFan]

Welcome to hR John. Glad to have a Bronco IFS dude here!

Marino.:D

[Hailyeah]

Marino. Quick release, accuracy, efficient plus longevity. Hey, so many things outside of the QB's control have to come together in order for a QB to win the big one. If Terrell Davis hadn't come along, Elway probably would not have hoisted the trophy at all. Kelly was a fine QB in his own right though.

[NamVet4]

Kelly - sometimes looked more like an "NFC" type QB than a run of the mill AFC type QB

[bfauble83]

Had to go with Dan "The Man" Marino

[jsarno]

it's no contest, MARINO!
Kelley had one of the best backs in history in Thomas, Marino NEVER had that.
Kelley also had some outstanding defenses lead by Bruce Smith and company. Marino is hands down the better QB, it's a shame they never put a team around him.
I think the better poll would be Marino vs Elway.

[Spence]

I went with Marino. Aside from Elway, I can't really think of any quarterback in history I'd rather have than Marino.

[SkinsKY]

Good Poll

Went with Kelly. True Kelly more support than Danny and Danny was the better passer, but with time winding down I'd rather trust Kelly will the ball because Danny couldn't move if the play broke down.

[Green-Is-Good]

doug williams

[DallasSux]

Dan Marino

[TexSkin]

I would take Joe Montana above all other though. He is my favorite QB of all time.

[Hailyeah]

Originally posted by TexSkin
I would take Joe Montana above all other though. He is my favorite QB of all time.

You mean other than the immortal Tony Banks, right? :thinker:

[TexSkin]

Originally posted by Hailyeah
You mean other than the immortal Tony Banks, right? :thinker:



:lol3: :lol3: :lol1: :lolbig: :funpost:

[Skinzaholic]

Dan... in a landslide

[jsarno]

Originally posted by TexSkin
I would take Joe Montana above all other though. He is my favorite QB of all time.


If we get to choose anyone...have to go with Steve Young...best passer rating of all time, and individual season not to mention his great scrambling ability. He had it all...accuracy, arm, feet, head, ability to win. He is the best of all time.

[TexSkin]

I hated Steve Young almost as much as I hate the Cowboys..I would not even let him be the waterboy on my fantasy team. :devil2:

[jsarno]

Originally posted by TexSkin
I hated Steve Young almost as much as I hate the Cowboys..I would not even let him be the waterboy on my fantasy team. :devil2:

Ahhhh, you must not be a fantasy guru...NEVER pick heart over players!!!!!

Steve Young was a flat out stud!

[rskinsfan10]

Marino easily.

[bfauble83]

Since everybody is saying who they would take over Marino/Kelly, I'd take Favre over either of them.

[SoCalRaider]

Who is Kelley? :twak:

[jsarno]

Originally posted by SoCalRaider
Who is Kelley? :twak:

QB for the Bills from 86-96! :spin:

(relax...I know it as mispelled.)

[TexSkin]

Your just mad cuz he used my stick of poo on you. :D

[jsarno]

Originally posted by TexSkin
Your just mad cuz he used my stick of poo on you. :D

:lol1::funpost: :lol3:

very true...you've taken quite a liking to that stick of poo haven't you?