Which Quarterback do you fear more?

[Taco John]

Which quarterback do you fear more?

Jake Plummer or Trent Green?

[Hailyeah]

Neither, but I voted for Green simply because he's actually competent. Plummer is a complete stiff IMO. Overexuberance instead of poise.

Are you an AFC West guy, TJ? Welcome.

[LuvSkins17]

Welcome to hailRedskins Taco. We hope that you will be an active member and continue to kick it with us.


I voted for T. Green because he has held his own since leaving Norv. I did like Trent when he was here with us too.

[Spence]

Plummer has never had a year like Green did last year.

[TexSkin]

Welcome Taco John good poll but it belongs in the All NFL forum as not Skins related...

I voted Plummer as well..I think the Snake will do good this year.

[SkinsKY]

Jake Plummer has to be the most overrated QB right now, maybe second next to Kordell. I have never heard so much praise heaped on a guy who has accomplished so little. Trent did put up some good numbers and Jake the Fake has never impressed me.

[LadyNRedskinsfan]

neither really scare me, but i choose plummer because he is mobile. i fear there RBs though...

[Green-Is-Good]

green. he throws too many picks, but he makes up for it by throwing touchdowns. plummer has not had a good td/int ratio the past few years. plummer once tried a behind-the-back pass to marcel shipp. just hand it off. he belongs in the NBDL, not the NFL.

[bfauble83]

Neither...

[hail2skins]

Neither but I voted Trent.

[JoeDaSchmoe]

Plummer, because the one year he had something that barely resembled a decent supporting cast, if you squinted and had that filmy sort of stuff over your eyes, he did the impossible and not only led the Arizona Cardinals to the playoffs, but even won a game there. Not to say he's the next coming of Brett Favre, but I think there's more there than with Green.

[Skins57]

I think Plummer will shine in Denver

[Skinzaholic]

Have to agree here... The Snake had little to work with... Trent had a ton more in KC...

[Seebs]

Sorry but I can't go for the orange man now. Choose Trent...

[RedskinRyan]

i'll go with trent, only cause he was a skin. plummer just hasnt fit in yet, while green has had success everywhere.

[jporterweb]

I saw Trent last night at the Hall of Fame game and in warmups, the man looked tough. Completed some tough passes, ran for some tough yards too.

[PennSkinsFan]

Had to go with Trent considering how many Career picks Champ had had on Jake Plummer

[HollywoodKolt]

Trent Green he had a great year last year and plummer has never been a player until the 4th quarter. 21 career 4th quarter comebacks but how many times has he not been able to bail himself out of his 1st through 3rd quarter mistakes

[IowaSkinsFan]

Welcome and Props to Taco.

Voted for Green. I thought we should have kept him over trading for Johnson in '99, but the whole ownership fiasco sent him packing. He is much more polished and accomplished than Plummer.

I also agree with Kolt. Very good points on Plummer.