Who would you rather have???

[ShaggySkins]

Realistically guys we won't be able to sign Milloy and Champ to long deals. So here is the question who would you rather have. Now don't forget Champ would make a decent amount more then Lawyer. Lawyer is looking at around 4-5 million a season, Champ would likely be around 8-10 million per season.

[BigCountry]

Milloy's deal was supposed to be that amount over 2 years. Readit in the washington post...

[NCskinsfanatic]

I voted Champ with the emphasis being on "rather have".However i don't believe Champ wants to stay here, so i say go after Milloy.The FO knows whether or not he will resign or for that matter if he truely wants to be here or not.If he doesnt we should lay down the $ and get a proven leader with great work ethic and a fire inside to match.This guy is not Sam Shade ,he's the real deal.

[PennSkinsFan]

I went with Malloy, cause i want someone who would want to be here.

[rhyno]

of course Bailey is the better player, the better impact player. I am realy turned off by him right now and I think that having milloy at 2.5/year for a few years would be more benificial to the club. that would give more signing room for arrington, the true staple of the defense. at least he wants to be here...

[REDMAN]

much rather have Champ! elite players like him are hard to find. Lawyer is a fantastic player, but he is not in his prime like Champ.

[J33Edwards]

how did Milloy get 4 votes to Champs 5...you guys must really be down on him from the post about him not wanting to be here.

A young stud corner who will keep getting better or a stud safety who is better against the run then the pass and has reached the top of his potential and has leveled off (if not started to decline)...its a no brainer to me

[AZ#1SkinsFan]

Originally posted by PennSkinsFan
I went with Malloy, cause i want someone who would want to be here.

AGREE 100%

[Green-Is-Good]

If we lose Champ, we will need a CB. Not a safety. Neither Ohalete nor Bowen are good enough in coverage to play corner.

[Skins57]

I went with Champ. he is younger,and has many more prime years left. I just wish there wasn't a question of Champ wanting to be here at all. Hopefully if we have a good playoff run this year that will change

[hail2skins]

Seems like Milloy didn't want to be here so I voted for the guy that is already here.

[dj_stouty]

So neither of the two options want to be here. GREAT...

[Hailyeah]

C'mon guys. We've got the Champ for 16 more games at the very least. He's one of ours. You'll feel foolish later if he re-ups in midseason.

[Green-Is-Good]

After hearing all this talk of him not wanting to be here, I don't think I mind if he is not re-signed.

[JoeDaSchmoe]

Champ's younger and the best at his position.

[Spence]

Originally posted by Hailyeah
C'mon guys. We've got the Champ for 16 more games at the very least. He's one of ours. You'll feel foolish later if he re-ups in midseason.
Amen! Thank you. This one isn't even close. Champ by a country mile.

[IowaSkinsFan]

I went with Champ as far as who I would rather have, based on age, skill, etc. However, I don't want Champ if he doesn't want to be here. I am always concerned how much effort a player will give when he is in a city where he doesn't want to be.

[Patrick]

Will have to settle with Champ for the next two seasons.