Grade The Skins vs Giants Thread

[hail2skins]

Offense
Defense
Special Teams
Coaching

[Redskinmayhem]

Offense - c+ : We started clicking too late and Samuels and that O-line are getting on my last nerve w/ all the holdding pen.
defense - c- : the d-line is pretty porous, Lavar had a missed tackle trotter didn't do to well, and Armstead alwasy gets owned by the giants. Forget about champ and fred, bowen and Iffy were OK.
ST - c : some nice returns but missed FG's. That killed us.
Coaching - B+ : spurrier put us in the best position to win the game.

[AustinSkins]

Offense - C- Too many dropped balls, stupid O-Line penalties
Defense - C+ Held them when they had too (except OT), poor pass rush
Special Teams - B Pretty good, could get alot better
Coaching - B No real problems here

[NCskinsfanatic]

O=(C-)9 drops,umpteen dozen penalties ruin good performance by Ramsey,Betts,McCants.
D=(C-))Solid against the run,NO pass rush as feared,stupid penalties at the worst possible times.
ST=(C+)Looked pretty solid,Morton actually got a little blocking,missed FG's hurt,especially the second one it was makeable.
C=(B)Spurrier didnt drop the balls,hold or commit false starts.He also wasnt to blame for our inability to get to the QB!

[Skinzaholic]

Offense- (C-) - Same reasons as stated... penalties were the worst... dropped passes ruined numerous gains. Missed scoring opportunities right and left.

Defense (C) - Not a bad job overall... but as stated, no, none, zilch pass rush at all... and failed to hold them when we needed it the most.

Special Teams (B) - Nice runs... good blocking... missed field goals sucked (especially knowing Hall can make them). Nice punting by Barker... (poor down field coverage).

Coaching (B) - Great job by Spurrier at calling plays. I think he should have run more on the drive at top of 4th qtr instead of Ramsey forcing it and almost getting it picked off.

[Odyn]

Offense
Running Game - A- (Got behind had to forego the run)
Passing Game - B+ (Drops and Ramsey throwing ball up for grabs, when was the last time we had a QB that could throw on the run, Ramsey is the real deal)
Offensive Line - C-
Defense
Defensive Line - D (Couldn't stop the run, no pressure on Collins)
Defensive Backs - D (New nick name - The Myths)
Special Teams - C
Coaching - B (I like Spurrier calling running plays when we were backed up so Ramsey wouldn't throw an INT that could end the game)

[Spence]

Offense: C
Defense: C
Special Teams: B
Coaching: C

[JoeDaSchmoe]

Offense: B-. Mainly because of their performance in the second half.
Defense: C. Don't kill us in overtime. It doesn't help you get a good grade.
Special Teams: C. I'm glad we got John Hall, I really am, but 2/4 hurts. Oh, and with time, I might be able to push the image of two Redskins running into each other when they were trying to tip a punt back in play out of my head.
Coaching: C+. Spurrier called another good game, although in the beginning he was a bit too pass-happy for my liking. It's Edwards that's starting to bug me. He knows we can't get a pass rush, he knows their offensive line is terrible, and yet we hardly blitz! And when we do, it's Arrington coming up right on the line five seconds before the snap, not even attempting to disguise anything. Did Trotter or Armstead blitz once tonight? How about the safeties?

[BigCountry]

Offense- C (penalties alone. You need to be pretty self destructive to get 456 against a good defense and not win)

Defense- F (They failed the whole team in that overtime drive)

Special teams- B (Pretty good overall)

Coaching- B+ (Gotta feel for Spurrier after this one)

[hail2skins]

Offense C - Got going a bit late but good adjustments to what the Giant's defense was doing.
Defense C - People are wondering if they ran out of gas in the overtime.
Special Teams B - Well, Brian didn't run one back. That's a good thing.
Coaching C - Spurrier and his staff need to manage the play clock better. They take too long deciding what package and play they want.

[dj_stouty]

Offense - B (Ramsey and Coles are a tandem made in heaven)
Defense - C (They got ran over in the first half...and in OT, when it counted)
Special Teams - B (Morton actually moved the ball downfield!)
Coaching - B+ (Spurrier, once again, did a good job of adjusting at 1/2 time)

[bfauble83]

Offense-C
Defense-C
Special Teams-C
Coaching-C

[Patrick]

OFFENSE: C
line: D
wr: C
te: D
rb: C
qb: B-

DEFENSE: D
line: D
lb: C-
db: D

SPECIAL TEAMS: C
punt: C
pr: C
ko:C-
fg:C-

Coaching: F

Bottomline: A good coaching staff will ensure displine. Had the same problem with penalities in the preseason and nothing has been done about it. Time to start laying 10% of the per game salary fines.

[AZ#1SkinsFan]

Originally posted by hail2skins
Offense
Defense
Special Teams
Coaching

Offense C - (F for 1st half - A for second half)

Defense D - (Bad tackling, horrible in first have and OT)

Special Teams - B (coverage much better, Morton looked better, would have been nice if Hall could have hit one of the two he missed, but he did make the one that he should make and HAD to make).

Coaching D - (Bad game planning got the Skins behind early again - good adjustments, but part of that had to do with the Giants and how they played with the lead - horrible accountability to the players, meaning way to many penalties and part of that is on the coaching staff - where are the passes to trung? - also with as little pressure as we have been bringing, where are the blitzes?