Top Tens--- QB

[SkinsASchamps]

The season is about to start. It is the best time of year. One thing my friends and I like to do is make lists/rankings for NFL players. I thought it would be fun to see how peoples list would differ going into this season. So here is my list of top ten Qbs. Who are yours?


Top Ten QBs:

1. Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Kurt Warner
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Roethlisberger
7. McNabb
8. Rivers
9. Cutler
10. Hasslebeck

[Hr fan]

Where is Favre (and JC)?

[shally]

Where is Favre (and JC)?

favre aint it, any more...

and JC ?? you must be messing with me...lol

[dj_stouty]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Brees (First Tier)
4. Rivers
5. McNabb
6. Warner
7. Cutler
8. Big Ben
9. Romo
10. Rodgers

[SkinsASchamps]

Where is Favre (and JC)?

Favre is not top 15..

Ahead of Favre and close to top ten:

Garrard
Palmer
Eli Manning
Matt Ryan
Romo

[dj_stouty]

Favre is not top 15..

Ahead of Favre and close to top ten:

Garrard
Palmer
Eli Manning
Matt Ryan
Romo

I'd put Favre at 15th. These rankings are based on only this season, right? I think Favre will do very well in Minnesota and a guy like Palmer is coming off injury and their offense is pretty terrible these days.

I also think Flacco is staring to earn his keep enough to be considered top 15.

[LATrueRedskin]

My List:

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Phillip Rivers
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Ben Roethlisberger
7. Kurt Warner
8. Donovan McNabb
9. Jay Cutler
10. Matt Ryan

[shally]

1. colt
2.colt
3.colt
4.colt
5.colt
6.colt
7.colt
8.colt
9.colt
10. chase............................




lol

[akhhorus]

My standard would be who could I pick regardless of salary:

1. Brady
2. Brees
3. Big Ben
4. Peyton
5. Rivers
6. Rogers
7. McNabb
8. Garrard
9. Palmer
10. Matt Ryan

[akhhorus]

1. colt
2.colt
3.colt
4.colt
5.colt
6.colt
7.colt
8.colt
9.colt
10. chase............................




lol

Heavenly father, guide this empty bourbon bottle towards Shally's head lol

[Fathead]

1. colt
2.colt
3.colt
4.colt
5.colt
6.colt
7.colt
8.colt
9.colt
10. chase............................




lol



Do not open any suspicious mail from Idaho. I'm not sure I can stop myself.

[SkinsASchamps]

I'd put Favre at 15th. These rankings are based on only this season, right? I think Favre will do very well in Minnesota and a guy like Palmer is coming off injury and their offense is pretty terrible these days.

I also think Flacco is staring to earn his keep enough to be considered top 15.

This is all subjective. I am planning to put up other positions too (WR, RB Etc) but we could expand it to a top 20? I just think top ten is more manageable.

Flacco is coming along nicely. He is close but I would rather have all the guys I mentioned before him.

[CarMike]

Where is Favre (and JC)?

He said top 10. Not top 22.

[Patrick]

Based on 2009 performance NOT W/L
1. Rivers
2. Pennington
3. Warner
4. Brees
5. Manning
6. Rodgers
7. Schaub
8. Ryan (this should be Romo place but just can't do it)
9. Garcia
10. Brady (even though he did nothing to deserve this based on 2009)

[ClubSandwichGuy]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Philip Rivers
5. Aaron Rodgers
6. Kurt Warner
7. Ben Roethlisberger
8. Carson Palmer
9. Donovan McNabb
10. Matt Ryan

[Ibleedburgundy]

1. Brady
2. Brees
3. Manning
4. Roethlisberger
5. Rivers
6. Warner
7. McNugget
8. Garrard
9. Rodgers
10. Ryan

[shally]

Heavenly father, guide this empty bourbon bottle towards Shally's head lol

you could at least leave one swallow left in it...lol

[shally]

just curious how much love there is for Aaron Rodgers.. has he done anything yet to deserve that kind of adulation ?

[akhhorus]

just curious how much love there is for Aaron Rodgers.. has he done anything yet to deserve that kind of adulation ?

The 4000+ yards and 32 total TDs last year did it for me.

[csquared]

The 4000+ yards and 32 total TDs last year did it for me.

No kidding. When was the last time the Skins have gotten that from any QB?

[HAWGZHEAD]

1. Brady
2. Brees
3. Manning
4. Roethlisberger
5. McNabb
6. Rodgers
7. Rivers
8. Warner
9. Ryan
10. Palmer

[akhhorus]

No kidding. When was the last time the Skins have gotten that from any QB?

There's been only 2 Qb single year performances over 4000 yards for the skins: Schroder in 1986 and Brad Johnson in 1999. Jurgensen had the most single season TDs in a season for a skins QB: 31 in 67.

So, its been a bit rare lol

[shally]

The 4000+ yards and 32 total TDs last year did it for me.

that kind of flew below radar for me.. but then they didnt do that well in the playoffs

[shally]

There's been only 2 Qb single year performances over 4000 yards for the skins: Schroder in 1986 and Brad Johnson in 1999. Jurgensen had the most single season TDs in a season for a skins QB: 31 in 67.

So, its been a bit rare lol

in '67, how many games per year were they playing ? was it 16 then ?

edit: 14 games 6-7-1 record

[skinsfan36]

1.Brady
2.Brees
3.Peyton Manning
4.Rivers
5.Cutler
6.mcnabb
7.roethlisburger
8.Ryan
9.Rodgers
10.Elisha manning

[dj_stouty]

I like how Rodgers throws for 4,000 and he is automatically annointed; yet Cutler throws for 4,500 yards and every excuse possible is created to downplay his performance.

I don't think 4,000+ yards comes by accident, so I think both guys are poised to be good to great NFL QBs. But I still think Rodgers could slip; so my jury is still out on him. I don't see him throwing 4K every year like Manning can. If you look back to 2008, his best two games were against Detroit. (600+ yards; 6TDs)

I think Rodgers will have a big test this year; especially since he will get to faced Baltimore and Pittsburgh.

[akhhorus]

I like how Rodgers throws for 4,000 and he is automatically annointed; yet Cutler throws for 4,500 yards and every excuse possible is created to downplay his performance.


I think Cutler is a good QB, but imo he's crowded out by other guys who produced very well without the talent he had in Denver. If he puts up 4000 yards with Hester and Earl Bennett as his WRs and the oline they have, then he's top 10 for certain.

[hockeygoalie29]

This article fits this thread very nicely. A breakdown of the top 49 quartetrbacks in the NFL, done by Trent Dilfer. I'm only part way through it, but it is very refreshing to see an article on ESPN (or any site for that matter) that is legitimate and not done just to provoke a response. Well done Trent.

Link (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/preview09/columns/story?columnist=dilfer_trent&id=4436281)

[squirrel]

1. Brady
2. Peyton
3. Big Ben
4. Brees
5. Warner
6. Rivers
7. Romo
8. Rogers
9. McNibble
10. Palmer

[dj_stouty]

This article fits this thread very nicely. A breakdown of the top 49 quartetrbacks in the NFL, done by Trent Dilfer. I'm only part way through it, but it is very refreshing to see an article on ESPN (or any site for that matter) that is legitimate and not done just to provoke a response. Well done Trent.

Link (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/preview09/columns/story?columnist=dilfer_trent&id=4436281)

Thanks for posting this. Great job by Trent...and I really can't argue with any of his rankings.

[SpicyMcHaggis]

1. Brady
2. Peyton
3. Big Ben
4. Brees
5. Warner
6. Rivers
7. Romo
8. Rogers
9. McNibble
10. Palmer

Dude, post more. Much more.