Luck or RGIII

[hail2skins]

Originally Posted by cal_junior

Agreed. The idea that Luck won't be able to succeed within four years in Indy is a little over-the-top. When you have a stud at QB the turnaround from crap to respectable is pretty quick. I'll be surprised if the Colts aren't in the playoffs by his third season, to be honest.

I agree with this and I was very comfortable if we would have wound up with Luck.

I'm listening to Luck's coach at Stanford on the NFL Network and this guy is impressive. I'm sure he'll be in the NFL soon. A college coach that runs a pretty good pro offense. Not too bad.

[AustinSkin]

Originally Posted by hail2skins

I know you are a RG III enthusiasts but declaring before the draft that Luck will be a bust in a year or two is pretty bad. There are some on here that think a good QB can elevate a bad team. Seems like Luck could fall in that category.

Also, don't go thinking that we are that much better than the Colts. That would be a mistake.

I am an RGIII enthusiast, and I wish Andrew Luck no ill will whatsoever. On the surface it appears that Indy is a team in serious disrepair, and it's going to take a while to assemble a cast of supporting characters to allow Luck to be effective as a QB in this league.

I also believe that if RGIII were drafted by Indy, he would be in the same conundrum.

[hail2skins]

Originally Posted by AustinSkin

I am an RGIII enthusiast, and I wish Andrew Luck no ill will whatsoever. On the surface it appears that Indy is a team in serious disrepair, and it's going to take a while to assemble a cast of supporting characters to allow Luck to be effective as a QB in this league.

I also believe that if RGIII were drafted by Indy, he would be in the same conundrum.

Again, we're not that much better. It could happen to us too.

[AustinSkin]

Originally Posted by hail2skins

Again, we're not that much better. It could happen to us too.

Agreed, it could happen, but I'm just not feeling it. I think we are much further along than Indy, but time will tell.