Best Redskin Ever

[Aurej]

Slinging Sammy Baugh, only man to every lead the league in Passing, Passing TD's, Interceptions(as a defensive back), and Punting in the same year(he did it twice).

[smoot]

i agree, thats crazy

[Carmelo]

Originally Posted by Aurej

Slinging Sammy Baugh, only man to every lead the league in Passing, Passing TD's, Interceptions(as a defensive back), and Punting in the same year(he did it twice).

That sounds like a player I created on madden, not something out of the nfl.

[CarMike]

Moving to the Tribe since its Redskins related.

[I think this is a first for moving something into the Tribe....

[dogfight6]

Pat Fisher is my choice. {Ask Harold Carmicheal why}.

[redwolf1218]

Originally Posted by dogfight6

Pat Fisher is my choice. {Ask Harold Carmicheal why}.

that brings up some good memories. i remember those matchups between carmicheal with the eagles, at something like 6'-5, and our pat fisher, at something like 5'-7. and pat fisher shutting him down. i remember an interview with fisher a long time ago, he said the teams back then under george allen were so close, if he was in a bar today, and there was some trouble, he could make a phone call, and in about 10 minutes have 5 or 6 guys there standing by him.

[flave1969]

For me it has too be Darrell Green. He dominated his position. Teams stayed away from him and he still had over 50 INT's in his career. He was a good tackler. The NFL's fastest man. Remember him coming out of nowhere to tackle Tony Dorsett. Remember the Punt return at Soldier Field. He played in 295 games and has two SuperBowl rings and is a 7 time Pro Bowler.

[redwolf1218]

Originally Posted by flave1969

For me it has too be Darrell Green. He dominated his position. Teams stayed away from him and he still had over 50 INT's in his career. He was a good tackler. The NFL's fastest man. Remember him coming out of nowhere to tackle Tony Dorsett. Remember the Punt return at Soldier Field. He played in 295 games and has two SuperBowl rings and is a 7 time Pro Bowler.

i agree...Green. i went off on a tangent about fisher because it was a good memory, but Green was, and still is, a great man. great football player, great family man. i remember him running down dorsett, he comes into the replay like a blur. also erik dickerson. i remember hearing phil simms say that he was told by Parcells not to even look to green's side of the field. that's respect.

[Patrick]

Without a doubt, in my mind it will always be Darrell Green. One of the longest careers in the NFL and done only on one team - that's worth alot!!!

[PainterBoy]

Originally Posted by flave1969

For me it has too be Darrell Green. He dominated his position. Teams stayed away from him and he still had over 50 INT's in his career. He was a good tackler. The NFL's fastest man. Remember him coming out of nowhere to tackle Tony Dorsett. Remember the Punt return at Soldier Field. He played in 295 games and has two SuperBowl rings and is a 7 time Pro Bowler.

Sentimental pick - yes! Statistical pick - No!

Darrell's heroics on and off the field are very fresh in most posters mind, thus he will be remembered quickly! Heck half the posters on this board probably can't even recall Darrell Green's first years because they are fairly young.

However, even in Darrell's best days he wasn't even known as the best corner in the NFL - Deion stakes that claim!

Sammy Baugh's records and stats are unbelievable and would have to be the greatest Redskin! He could arguably be the greatest NFL player ever.

Others that I would put on the consideration list:

1. Baugh
2. C. Taylor - greatest receiver ever before Rice came along.
3. Jurgenson - best passer Skins had - statistically great
4. Green/Fisher - take your pick of greatest DB in Skins history
5. Hanburger
6. Monk

Those are greats I came up with quickly, I might necessarily put them in that order at least from 3 down without a little more thought.

[IowaSkinsFan]

Originally Posted by CarMike

Moving to the Tribe since its Redskins related.

[I think this is a first for moving something into the Tribe....

LOL. Quite right. You never know what you'll see if you stick around long enough.

[smoak]

Originally Posted by Carmelo

That sounds like a player I created on madden, not something out of the nfl.

it was a much different NFL back then.

[flave1969]

Originally Posted by PainterBoy

Sentimental pick - yes! Statistical pick - No!

Darrell's heroics on and off the field are very fresh in most posters mind, thus he will be remembered quickly! Heck half the posters on this board probably can't even recall Darrell Green's first years because they are fairly young.

However, even in Darrell's best days he wasn't even known as the best corner in the NFL - Deion stakes that claim!

Sammy Baugh's records and stats are unbelievable and would have to be the greatest Redskin! He could arguably be the greatest NFL player ever.

Others that I would put on the consideration list:

1. Baugh
2. C. Taylor - greatest receiver ever before Rice came along.
3. Jurgenson - best passer Skins had - statistically great
4. Green/Fisher - take your pick of greatest DB in Skins history
5. Hanburger
6. Monk

Those are greats I came up with quickly, I might necessarily put them in that order at least from 3 down without a little more thought.

I would not argue with any of the players listed. Lets face it all the guys you listed mean an awful lot to us all.Trust me Darrell was not a sentimental pick for me. But too me it is all about the team, and for twenty years we did not have to worry about a position. As for Deion Sanders he was a great player in his day. Darrell had played six seasons before Deion reached the league. Simply because he was not the best in the NFL should not reflect on his career as a Redskin. I would put Baugh up there he was truly one of a kind in his era.

It is a difficult thing to pick one guy.

[smoak]

Originally Posted by PainterBoy

However, even in Darrell's best days he wasn't even known as the best corner in the NFL - Deion stakes that claim!

deion was a low class person and while i agree that DG may not have been considered the BEST corner, he was ALWAYS considered to be a great CB. plus to be the best redskins, i do not think you have to be the BEST player to have played for the redskins. DG never played for another team and did a lot for the community. he was one of the best pro athletes ever and should be in both the NFL and "good person" halls of fame...

all that said, i vote gibbs.

[Carmelo]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Without a doubt, in my mind it will always be Darrell Green. One of the longest careers in the NFL and done only on one team - that's worth alot!!!

His loyalty was priceless to me. Just one class act guy.