Edgerrin James or Kevin Barlow?

[B'More Skinsfan]

I'm in a keeper league. I have the 2nd pick and it looks like the top two RB's available will be EJ and Barlow. I think Ej is a far better value. Just looking for some insight.

[IndianBaller27]

I think Edge is better. But with the second pick shouldn't there be better players than Edge and Barlow?

[B'More Skinsfan]

Thanks for the input. I'm in a keeper league, so all of the better players are already on teams.

[skins111111]

play it safe or take a chance???? I am looking at Edge (3 yrs removed from his injury) to put up some big #s in Indy. They have to establish the running game to have the air game up to its full potential.................Then again this is Barlows chance to shine, he's all alone in SF and I mean all alone. They will stack the box on him but do we have the next LT or close to it. If so how would he fit in your keeper league?...........Edge is pretty much a sure thing.

[RedskinsDave]

Edge is also in a contract year. I don't think there should even be a question but he is due to bust out this year.

[B'More Skinsfan]

It's a moot point now. I traded my 1st round pick for Clinton Portis. I'll take that any day.

[IMALILTEAPOT]

i'll say Kevan Barlow cuz hes gonna be there only offense and Edge is in a passing system. But I do think Edge is better thou, but Barlow will break out

[JoeJacksonTaylor28]

I would go with Edge even with my eyes shut.